Hollywood Legend Nearly the Same Age as Kevin Costner May Be the Answer to Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone Problem But it Comes With a Huge Risk

Follow us on Google News

Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed

Yellowstonehas been the root of many evils for almost 2 years now. Deterioration in the quality of writing, Kevin Costner’s frayed relationship with Taylor Sheridan, premature cancelation of the show 2 seasons before its supposed ending, and an ongoing lawsuit between Sheridan and one of his lead actors are just a few of the many things that have been going awry since the series last aired.

Kevin Costner inYellowstone[Credit: Paramount Network]Now that the television Western is finally returning with Season 5, Part 2, fans have expectantly hoped for a climactic finale to the story that has entertained viewers for the better part of the last 7 years. However, as the series begins filming its final few episodes, the biggest dilemma is whether Kevin Costner will return as John Dutton for one last time, or if his pride will get the better of him.

Kevin Costner’s Return Remains a Distant Dream

In the ambitious and cut-throat world ofYellowstone, the patriarch of the Dutton family is the only steadfast pillar around which the rest of the characters, plots, and drama revolve and intersect. WithoutKevin Costner‘s John Dutton, the entire narrative ofYellowstonebecomes moot, giving the series no meaning or cause to fight over or build on. The characteristic cruelty and apathy with which Costner brought his character to life has been the show’s signature identity.

Kevin Costner as John Dutton [Credit: Paramount Network]However, the behind-the-scenes drama surrounding the filming schedule of Season 5 and Costner’s long wait before moving on to his passion project,Horizon: An AmericanSaga, drove the actor to walk out of his contractual obligation to Sheridan. AsCostner revealedduring an interview withDeadline, despite waiting for 14 months to begin filming Part 2,“The scripts never came.”

‘Yellowstone’ Creator Taylor Sheridan Pulled off One Feat Many Big Directors Will Find Hard to do And it Shows Just How Much Kevin Costner Helped the Franchise

In his absence, the Paramount+ series has moved on with the remaining cast asTaylor Sheridandrives his show to the finish line. Despite Costner publicly admitting that he’d be open to returning for the series finale, the water has become too muddied for all parties to reconcile and head back to filming without further ado.

Should John Dutton be Recast After Kevin Costner’s Exit?

Dennis Quaid inVegas(2012) [Credit: CBS]For some time now,Yellowstonefans have been concerned about the fate of John Dutton in Season 5, since Sheridan is against the policy of disrespectfully killing characters off-screen without giving them proper closure. Considering how Costner is the main lead ofYellowstone, it will be difficult for the show’s creator to end his arc in a“f*ck-you car crash”due to their off-screen dispute.

The only remaining solution then is to recast the character of John Dutton with another actor equally qualified to fill in Costner’s shoes. As oneReddituser claimed,Dennis Quaidas John would be the perfect fit in many respects – with age and filmography being two of the primary and most important factors.

Both actors (aged 9 months apart) have reigned in Hollywood as venerated A-listers throughout the 80s and 90s. Moreover, just like Kevin Costner,The Right Stuffactor has starred in numerous Westerns as well, most famously,The Long Riders(1980),Wyatt Earp(1994), andThe Alamo(2004).

“I don’t do f—k you car crashes”: Taylor Sheridan Might Not Like Kevin Costner Anymore But He Won’t Insult Him With His Yellowstone Fate After Series Exit

Kevin Costner, who has been known for his extraordinary love for and mastery of the Western genre, has left an irreversible imprint on the character of John Dutton. From a subjective viewpoint, recasting him would be an absolute travesty. However, the character of John Dutton was written in service to the show,Yellowstone, and if recasting him can bring the story to its proper conclusion, the smarter choice would be to get Dennis Quaid to stand in for John Dutton for the last 8 episodes.

But such a straightforward solution comes with its own risk. Considering how loyalYellowstone‘s fanbase has grown to be, recasting such a central character in Paramount’s flagship show will not only affect the series ratings but Sheridan’s reputation as a producer as well. As such, the dilemma surrounding the recasting of Kevin Costner’s John Dutton is as legitimate as it can get.

YellowstoneSeason 5, Part 2 will stream exclusively on Paramount+ in November 2024.

Diya Majumdar

Senior Writer

Articles Published :2409

Diya Majumdar is a Senior Content Writer at FandomWire with over 2000 published articles on the website. Since 2022, she has been working as an entertainment journalist with a special focus on films and pop culture.Among the countless genres and themes of Hollywood, the ones that particularly favor Diya’s tastes include Game of Thrones, DC, and well-aged thrillers and classics.

More from Diya Majumdar

The Darkest Star Wars Movie Is Proof Robert Pattinson’s Batman Can Work in James Gunn’s DCU

Kevin Hart Is Trading Dwayne Johnson for Another WWE Star in New Netflix Film

Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein First Look Photos Decoded: Is it the Darkest Netflix Film Yet?

Recommended

New ‘Harry Potter’ BTS Image Reveals Nick Frost’s Shockingly Perfect Look as Hagrid

Upload Season 4: How Many Episodes Will the Final Season Have?

Japan’s 10 Most-Watched Anime of 2025: Naruto Not Even in Top 5

18 Years Later, 47%-rated Mark Wahlberg Action Blockbuster Is Still Conquering Streaming

Ne Zha Ending Explained: How The Major Deaths Set Up Ne Zha 2?

When Is Tyler Perry’s Beauty in Black: Season 2 Releasing?

Dennis QuaidKevin CostnerYellowstone